In the span of a single week, three separate universities found themselves facing hazing investigations serious enough to draw national news coverage, and reporters turned to our own Michael Levine and David Bianchi for perspective on each one.
Taken together, these cases say a lot about how little progress has been made on hazing prevention, university transparency, and accountability when students are harmed.
NC State: Sigma Nu
At North Carolina State University, ABC11 reports that search warrants in the Sigma Nu investigation describe pledges being beaten, forced to take drugs, and made to vomit into another pledge's mouth. No charges have been filed yet, but Michael Levine, who has represented families in hazing cases nationwide, didn't mince words about what the allegations amount to. "It's disturbing and disgusting, and it's also illegal," he told ABC11.
Levine also pointed out that criminal charges, if they come, likely wouldn't be the end of the legal exposure here. In the civil cases he's handled, chapter officers, members directly involved, and even chapter advisors have all ended up as defendants. It's a pattern our firm has seen before: after Andrew Coffey died in a 2017 FSU hazing incident, the case against the fraternity brothers involved reached well beyond whoever handed him the bottle.
West Virginia University
WSAZ asked Levine for his take on a very different piece of the puzzle: why WVU sought search warrants at all. Three fraternities are under investigation there: Pi Kappa Alpha and Lambda Chi Alpha, where warrants were executed last month, and Delta Sigma Phi, where it's unclear whether one was issued. Lambda Chi Alpha has been suspended since the investigation began, while Pi Kappa Alpha has continued operating as normal, a discrepancy WSAZ has yet to get an explanation for.
Levine told WSAZ that warrants are unusual at this stage of a hazing investigation, typically surfacing only after someone has already died. He also flagged WVU’s silence on its own disciplinary transparency reports, which its hazing prevention website says should be published every semester but haven’t been since 2023. "It's a little strange to me," he said of how the records in this case have been handled. “Those are questions that ought to be followed up aggressively with West Virginia University.”
Florida State: Chi Phi
The most disturbing allegations this week came out of Florida State, where WCTV reports a new member of Chi Phi was allegedly tied up and locked in a car trunk, then driven to an unknown location and pressured to use cocaine and alcohol. Other new members were reportedly made to pull overnight "watch" shifts at the chapter house and perform personal errands for existing brothers. FSU has placed Chi Phi under a partial suspension, barring new member events and anything involving alcohol, while the university's police department investigates.
David Bianchi, who wrote much of Florida's Andrew's Law and represented Andrew’s family after his hazing death, said the allegations stand out among the cases he’s seen over the years. "That's one of the worst ones I've ever heard," he told WCTV. He also used the moment to explain what Andrew's Law actually does: it grants immunity from prosecution to the first person who calls 911 during a hazing emergency, even if that person was involved in the hazing itself, because, as Bianchi has said before, most parents who've lost a child this way would trade any prosecution for having gotten the chance to save their son.
Three schools, three fraternities, three sets of allegations serious enough to warrant a criminal investigation, all surfacing within days of each other. OurĀ hazing attorneys have spent years representing families through exactly this kind of aftermath, and cases like these are why that work isn't finished.